Friday, September 5, 2014

Learned Behaviors

Perhaps it's my never-ending desire to see the good in everyone, rather than the bad, as being their primary driving motive. Perhaps I'm just being stubborn. Perhaps it's the fact that I haven't had anything to eat since breakfast and am therefore not thinking 100% straight. But I just don't believe that we as human being are inherently unjust. I feel that it is something which is taught to us from the moment of our birth, through our subconscious, from watching those around us. I believe that we are raised to fit into our society, not to be the most just, the most wise, and the most virtuous. That is why, in my opinion, we have things like the "hood" and "high class society."

Children born into “more virtuous” homes are raised that lying is ALWAYS wrong, and stealing is a crime. However, in those same homes, there can be heard a whispered, "but lying is okay in certain situations." How do we expect our young people to automatically know what those certain situations are? Also, when we teach that lying is always wrong, and then come back and undermine that statement by saying "but sometimes..." we are creating a situation in which the young people will start to question the edge parameters of when it's good to lie and when it's not. And they're right. Where is the line between right and wrong?

The same is true for the rest of the human population. I mean, if you think about it, why do behaviors of children and teenagers raised 200+ years ago seem so similar to the children and teenagers of today? I believe it is passed down from generation to generation, and we don't even mean to, or intend to inflict these expectations on our young. But we still do it. And our young have no other source to draw from except the imperfections of the human race. We’re taught from a young age that it’s survival of the fittest. And it is. Even if that means we sometimes have to lie, cheat, or do something else that is not entirely honest to be considered “the fittest.”

Now that I’m over my mild aggravation from Wednesday that I had toward my sister, the only thing I would change about my statements regarding what I would do with an invisibility ring, is this: I wouldn't sneak up on my sister to scare her. I would still like to get on a plane to go anywhere, but if I’m being truthful with myself, and I had the invisibility ring, I don’t think I would use it to get out of buying a ticket. I honestly believe that I would stay exactly the same as I am now, visible and able to receive punishment for my actions. I think the only reasons why I would ever use the ring would be to donate to people in need without being seen doing it, and to get away from people sometimes. Now, let me explain about the first one. I enjoy doing charity work simply to see how happy it makes people, or to see how it improves their life. I hate it when I give something to a friend simply as a gift, and knowing that they feel the urge to repay me for it. That defeats the purpose of me giving it to you. So I would use the ring to help people without being seen by those I’m helping. But that’s it. I wouldn't go rob a bank, kill a man, or anything like that. I just have zero desire to do anything like that. But maybe that’s just me?

Fear of the Law

If you gave a just and unjust person the freedom to commit a crime that benefits them, and comes without facing the consequences the just person would be as guilty as the unjust person.The just person would be more inclined to do wrong if there were no consequences attached to the wrong action.  Both parties have the same amount of freedom, and both of them will use it in which ever way they see it fit as their form of justice. The justice they both agree on is the justice that benefits their life style in the long run. They will both do wrong if the consequences are not enforced. They will do the crime continuously if they do not have to suffer the results of their wrong actions. The just person would in regular lawful justice no commit the crime for fear of getting punished. The unjust person would see the wrong action as a way out of the injustice situation the circumstances has put him in. The unjust person would take the risk over the current state of living he currently  presides  in.The lawful justice is being unfair to the unjust person, so he takes things into his own hands and breaks the rules to better his life. Where as the just person fears the law, and would rather continue to follow the law then face the consequences of breaking the laws.If the just person had a morality conflict going on in his/her head rather then the fear of the law, he/she would concur with the lawful choice because they would not be able to bear with the guilt or remorse of having broken a law. Both parties do what they think is right, and they choose what they think will make them happy or to have a happy life. An unjust person does not choose to do wrong by nature. An unjust person chooses to do wrong when the superior power allows them to have certain amount of freedom, wealth or when their way of life is not satisfying enough. The unjust person is formed by the circumstances and hard choices of life. The unjust person forms the ability to retain the guilt of committing a crime or breaking the law. Fear is used to make people follow the law. It is only broken when the person has no fear of the law, or can come to terms with the guilt of doing wrong to better their life.

Thrasymachus' Argument in Today's Society

In Plato’s Republic, Thrasymachus argues that justice equals the advantage of the strongest. The advantage of the strongest can be anything from personal gain to peace in society. Therefore, anyone who happens to be the strongest in any situation can decide what justice is and what it is not. In today’s society, this can apply to government officials, the laws put in place, and the way in which we practice said laws. One of the main qualities as the strongest is the authority that comes with it. Thrasymachus’ argument leaves it open-ended to where the advantage of the strongest can be or cannot be just. So although laws and government officials and their practices can define what justice is, that does not mean that this justice is just. In today’s society, there have been many controversies about cases where what is said to be justice by the strongest is not considered justice, or injustice, by the masses.

The first time injustice or justice in general ever crossed my mind was the Casey Anthony trial back in 2011. Casey Anthony was charged with the murder of her three year-old daughter Caylee back in 2008. The evidence shows that Anthony had traces of evidence in her car, and she also didn’t report her daughter missing when she hadn’t seen Caylee in 30 days. All of the evidence pointed to Casey Anthony, but she was found not guilty. Many people in the United States posted their outrage on social media. People called it shocking and compared it to the O.J. Simpson trial. To clarify, I am not saying that Casey Anthony did kill her daughter. I am just saying that evidence and media coverage led many people to believe that she was guilty. Therefore, this mass of people believed that the ruling was injustice – that Caylee did not receive justice. Applying this to Thrasymachus’ view point, the strongest would be the defense, judge, and jury. Their advantage is not letting a guilty woman go as some would say, but it is having the power to decide whether someone is guilty or not guilty. And this might cause injustice depending on the situation.

Some facts about the Casey Anthony trial can be found here: http://www.cnn.com/2013/11/04/us/casey-anthony-trial-fast-facts/


 


 
Another example of what people would believe to be injustice is the George Zimmerman
Trial in 2013. George Zimmerman was charged with the murder of Trayvon Martin in 2012. Zimmerman was a part of the neighborhood watch and called the police when he saw Martin walking through the neighborhood from a convenience store. Zimmerman was told by the dispatcher to not follow Martin, but Zimmerman did anyway. From there, the story gets a little fuzzy. The prosecution and defense have two different stories about who attacked who, but in the end, Martin was shot and killed by Zimmerman – self-defense or not. George Zimmerman was then found not guilty, and like the Casey Anthony trial, people were outraged. Unlike the Casey Anthony trial though, one of the main reasons people were outraged was because of racial issues. The media saw the murder as Zimmerman racially profiling Martin, a black teenager. However, the prosecution never brought this up in the case. They merely stated that Zimmerman judged Martin as a punk. Just like the Casey Anthony case, the strongest were the defense, judge, and jury, and the advantage is still the same.

 
Information about the George Zimmerman trial: http://www.cnn.com/2013/07/13/justice/zimmerman-trial/

 

 

 

In both cases, the verdict has been seen as injustice, and that the victims and their families do not get the justice they deserve. To clarify, I am not saying that people that make up the judges, juries, and defenses in both cases are morally unjust people. What I am saying is that by Thrasymachus’ definition of what is justice, these people as the strongest have made decisions which has caused some people to believe that it is injustice. Therefore, as the strongest in today’s societies, their decisions can be seen as injustice whether it be skewed by the media or the evidence or the case in general.

Plato's Republic - invisibility ring discussion

"Is it more profitable to be just or unjust?" In class on Wednesday, we had a discussion about what we would do if we were presented with the invisibility ring discussed in the book. A lot of people in class did not get a chance to participate (whether it was because of time constraints, shyness, or any other excuse), so I would like to discuss this question again but this time emphasizing on profitability. When I was asked by Dr. Johnson, I responded that I would commit crimes (more specifically, rob a bank) simply because without worrying about tying a name to a face (since we are invisible in this scenario), it is very profitable. Others in the class responded saying they would do nothing and just go about their day, which seems strange. I understand that there is personal guilt along with moral and religious issues involved when committing crimes, but I believe that everyone reading this would commit some kind of crime (small or large) if presented with the ring. If there are no consequences to our actions (robbing a bank while invisible for example), a lot of people would do it because it is profitable. We make decisions that are in our best interest for survival, so if presented with the chance to get away with crimes we would probably take it.

Glaucon asks, "what is justice and where did it come from?" One of the reasons we act "just" is because we are afraid of punishment or we are seeking rewards for being "just." I agree that it is more profitable to be unjust because if we were not punished for doing bad deeds, we would do them. What would you do with the invisibility ring? Regardless of what you choose to do with the invisibility ring, do you think that the unjust life is more profitable than the just?

"Strength"

As we discussed in class, when it comes to justice the strongest one will prevail. Now what type of "strength" can differ from situation to situation. During class we mostly all agreed that it was the "strongest" willed person that would be most justified. This was because if you have more will than your opponent, then common sense would say that you would win. More will does sound like the stronger, more justified person but I do see an opposite side to this. Even if the advantage of justice goes to the "strongest" person, I think that someone with more information could still have more justice. The person with more "strength" may have an advantage but even if they have all of the "strength" in the world if they don't have any information to back them up I don't see how they could have any justice at all. That also falls along with the rings in Plato's Republic, if a just man receives a ring that can allow him to turn invisible and do things he couldn't have done before he would turn into an unjust man. So accordingly, a man that was once just and had justice, after gaining "strength" becomes unjust so his sense of justice will become lessened making him a man of "strength" without justice. I see justice can be formed and perceived in many forms, one being the definition given in class of the one with the most "strength." Another form of obtaining justice is through a mass amount of knowledge of the subject or just a broad knowledge. Lastly I see the truth as a form of justice. Many times the truth can be hard to find because different people have different truths, but if the whole truth can be obtained then that can be used as a major source of justice. All three I see are Justice.

Thursday, September 4, 2014

Which Justice is the "right" Justice?

In the reading, there were two arguments presented on what justice is. The first argument by Glaucon is that people will do whatever is in their best interest which will usually come at the expense of someone else. Socrates argument is that people will do whatever is right regardless of if they benefit from it or not. For me it's hard to say that only one argument is correct since I see both sides. Speaking from personal experience (and I'm sure I'm not the only person that feels this way) a part of me always wants to do what is right or what is best for other people. To sacrifice what I really want for the happiness of everyone else, however part of me is still very selfish and doesn't care about if other people suffer because of an action or choice of mine. Where does one draw the line between what is just if what is "just" for the individual may not be "just" for the community? If I act in a way that is beneficial to me but not to someone else is what I'm doing just? It is what's right for me so if I don't do the action or what have you I would be acting in a way that is unjust to myself and is that better or worse than me doing something that is unjust to someone else? If we lived in an experimental "state of nature" I believe that Socrates' argument would fall flat because people would look out for their own interest only. I sincerely doubt that people would be concerned with if what they're doing is right/just if there is no one to tell them what they're doing is wrong/unjust, they would be more concerned with taking care of themselves at pretty much all costs.

Plato's Republic: Justice

     This excerpt from Plato’s Republic focuses on the question of “what is justice?” Thrasymachus made a very valid point in saying that justice works for the advantage of the strongest; which is sensible in the twenty-first century, and really throughout history. This does not mean that it works for the people who are worthy of justice, because everyone deserves justice. This means that whoever is seen as the most powerful in our society will have justice. One particular example could be the police in America. Many police officers do something that would be considered morally wrong, yet get away with it because they are the law, yet someone who could be defending themselves against a harmful person could be sentenced to many years in prison. One perfect example of the first observation involving the police, or the “strongest” according to what Thrasymachus said, would be the police officer, Darren Wilson of the Ferguson, MO police department. He was responsible for shooting Michael Brown, an unarmed and innocent black male. Although it has been proven that Michael Brown was unarmed and had not robbed the store in that area, the police department and many others stand by Darren Wilson, who so far, is going free. In this case, Darren Wilson and the Ferguson police department would be considered the “strongest” because they are the law. 
     Further proving this point would be the case of Marissa Alexander, a black Jacksonville, FL mother who was sentenced twenty years in prison for firing a warning shot in the air so that her abusive partner would go away. She was protecting herself, and in a way that did not harm anyone. Justice did not work for the advantage of Ms. Alexander because she does not have the power that others may have. For hundreds of years in America, minorities have had this problem where justice does not apply to them because of racism, which further proves Thrasymachus’ truth in proclaiming that justice works for the strongest, or the most powerful people in society.